top of page

The Pitfalls of Treat-Based Horse Training: Why Competence and Timing Matter

While treats can be a fun and seemingly effective tool in horse training, relying on them without a solid understanding of training principles and learning theory can lead to serious issues. Learn why competence, correct timing, and avoiding the trap of spoiling your horse are crucial for effective and ethical training.

In the world of horse training, the use of treats as a reward is a popular practice. However, treats alone cannot replace the competence and knowledge required for effective training. Understanding learning theory and proper training techniques is essential to ensure that your horse is not only responsive but also well-mannered, reliable, and performing healthy movements.

One significant downside of relying too heavily on treats is the risk of mistiming the reward. Timing is crucial in horse training; a treat given even a few seconds too late can reinforce the wrong behavior or even unhealthy movement. For instance, if a treat is given after a horse nudges you or becomes pushy, you’re inadvertently rewarding that undesirable behavior. Or if a horse is performing in an unhealthy way without proper biomechanics and you treat this the horse will offer more of this obviously desired response in the future. This can lead to confusion and frustration for the horse and can undermine your training efforts.

Furthermore, the overuse of treats done wrongly can spoil your horse, turning training sessions into a pursuit of snacks rather than an exercise in learning and discipline. Horses can become self-serving, focusing more on obtaining the treat than performing the desired behavior. This can erode the horse’s respect for the handler and lead to issues such as nipping, crowding, and other pushy behaviors.

The concept of becoming a “self-serving candy bar” is a real concern. When a horse starts seeing you only as a source of treats, the respect and bond that should be at the heart of your relationship can suffer. Training should build a partnership based on trust and mutual understanding, where food rewards can be a great tool to support this when done correctly.

Competence in horse training means understanding when and how to use treats effectively. It involves recognizing the importance of timing, consistency, and clear communication. Knowledge of learning theory helps you understand how horses think and learn, allowing you to shape their behavior more effectively and humanely. In addition, it is super important to be aware that you are always rewarding both the mental and emotional state and the physical quality, so keeping an eye on both is an essential part of training horses.

Furthermore, in general, it’s critical to build up the duration of training gradually (loopy training) and to structure sessions clearly. This approach not only helps in maintaining the horse’s focus but also ensures that the treat does not overshadow the training objectives.

Moreover, it is important to be aware of the risks associated with negative punishment by withholding treats. If a horse expects a treat for every correct behavior and it is withheld without a clear reason, it can lead to frustration and anxiety, potentially causing more harm than good. Ensuring that the horse understands the conditions under which treats are given is essential to prevent negative emotional responses.

Additionally, teaching your horse very good manners when taking treats is crucial. This includes training your horse to wait calmly for the treat and to take it gently, which reinforces respect and safety for both the horse and the handler.

Personally, I combine positive and negative reinforcement in my training approach, recognizing that positive reinforcement is not only characterized by food rewards. Positive reinforcement can include verbal praise, petting, and other forms of encouragement. Horses are very familiar with negative reinforcement through their herd dynamics, such as yielding to pressure from other horses. Finding an ethically correct way to combine these two types of reinforcement is key for me. It allows for a more balanced and natural training method that respects the horse's instincts and social behaviors.

In summary, while treats can be a super useful tool in horse training, they are no substitute for the knowledge and competence required to train a horse properly and you need to be well aware of their proper use. Misuse of treats, through poor timing, over-reliance, or inconsistent application, can lead to spoiled, confused, and even dangerous behaviors plus potentially develop unhealthy movement patterns, if you don't know better about healthy biomechanics.

By focusing on proper training techniques, understanding learning theory and healthy biomechanics, and incorporating treats in a structured and well-thought-through way, you can build a stronger, respectful, and effective partnership with your horse.

39 views0 comments


Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page